 |

|
| August 1999 Vol. 82, No. 8 |
A Pentagon study provides new details--about bravery, torture,
and endurance--on the experience of American POWs in Vietnam. |
Honor Bound
By Stewart M. Powell
|
|

American POWs in the Vietnam War endured the longest captivity of any group
of US wartime prisoners. One of them was Navy Lt. Paul Galanti, shown here
in an East German propaganda film, sitting under a sign that reads "Clean.
Neat."
Navy Capt. Jeremiah A. Denton was the senior officer
of the 40 Prisoners of War who left Hanoi on Feb. 12,
1973, aboard the first Air Force C-141 out of North
Vietnam. Once airborne, Denton calmly asked a flight
attendant for a piece of paper. He thought for a moment
and then scribbled the memorable words that he would
utter in a short time as he and his comrades stepped
off the airplane into the arms of freedom at Clark
AB in the Philippines.
"We are honored to have had the opportunity to
serve our country under difficult circumstances," Denton
declared. "We are profoundly grateful to our Commander
in Chief and to our nation for this day. God bless
America."
With that, the Navy pilot who went down in an A-6
carrier attack aircraft during a bombing run over North
Vietnam's Thanh Hoa bridge complex on July 19, 1965,
marked the end of the longest wartime captivity of
any group of US prisoners in history.
It was a triumph for Denton, who had alerted the world
to the communists' torture of prisoners in May 1966.
Dragged before propaganda cameras after 72 hours of
nonstop indoctrination, the sleep-deprived pilot had
numbly blinked his eyelids to relay the message "t-o-r-t-u-r-e" in
Morse code as a Japanese television news crew filmed
the interview.
A total of 771 Americans were captured and interned
during the Vietnam War. Of those, 113 died in captivity
and 658, or 85 percent, were returned to US authorities
during or at the end of a grueling conflict that claimed
the lives of more than 58,000 American troops in Southeast
Asia.
The number of prisoners taken during the Vietnam War
was relatively small. Of the 142,255 Americans captured
and interned during major wars in the 20th century,
a total of 17,033 died in captivity. The Korean War
had the highest casualty rate among US prisoners--with
38 percent of the 7,140 prisoners perishing.
For Americans searching for meaning in a controversial
conflict and yearning for heroes, the POWs became a
touchstone for the traditional values of loyalty and
inspiration often overlooked during the conflict itself.
|

Encouraged by the anti-war movement
in the US, Hanoi went to great lengths to present
its case through a persistent propaganda campaign
aimed at its own people and the world, in this
example staging the capture of a downed "pilot." In
propaganda films made about the time of the
Hanoi March, USAF F-105 pilot Capt. Murphy
Jones was paraded first bandaged and dirty,
clad in underwear, then (left) aboard a truck,
wearing his flight suit. Both films were part
of the North Vietnamese effort to establish
American pilots as "criminal aggressors" and "air
pirates."
|
The First POW
The first American taken prisoner by the Viet Cong
was Army Spec. 4 George F. Fryett, seized Dec. 26,
1961, while riding a bicycle on the way to a swimming
pool on the outskirts of Saigon. He was freed in June
1962: His captors simply came out of the jungle at
a main road and put him on a bus back to Saigon.
The last POW was seized Jan. 27, 1973-the day the
cease-fire was signed in Paris. Navy Lt. Cmdr. Phillip
A. Kientzler, shot down near the Demilitarized Zone,
was held for two months in North Vietnam under perhaps
the most benign conditions of the war, with captives
and captors awaiting prisoner releases. Kientzler was
freed March 27, 1973, with the last wave of captives
to go home.
Between these two bookends, the story of American
POWs unfolded. Their triumphs and tragedies are vividly
recaptured in Honor Bound: The History of American
Prisoners of War in Southeast Asia, 1961-1973. The
immensely detailed 592-page study was prepared by Stuart
I. Rochester, deputy historian of the Office of the
Secretary of Defense, and Frederick Kiley, a former
Air Force Academy professor and noted POW historian.
Drawing from memoirs, interviews, classified documents,
and other sources, the historians provide the most
sweeping view of American POWs since the return of
the prisoners in 1973.
"We were convinced in the end that, on the whole,
the PWs [the acronym commonly used by the military
services] of the Vietnam War were indeed an extraordinary
company of men who endured an extraordinary captivity," the
historians wrote. "Both suffering and valor, tragedy
and triumph, occurred on a large scale."
Prisoners captured and held in South Vietnam had a
far different experience than the aviator officers
shot down and held in the North. During the early years,
one out of three Americans taken prisoner was expected
to die in captivity--a toll reduced to one out of five
by war's end. In the North, only one in 20 captives
died in prison.
The longest held POW was captured in the South and
spent much of his imprisonment there. Army Ranger Capt.
Floyd J. "Jim" Thompson, commander of a Special
Forces detachment in Quang Tri Province, was captured
March 26, 1964, following the shootdown near the DMZ
of his low-flying reconnaissance aircraft. He was held
at a dozen jungle sites during the nearly nine years
before his release on March 16, 1973. Thompson's captivity
made him the longest held Prisoner of War in American
history.
In the North, Navy Lt. j.g. Everett Alvarez Jr. became
the first American pilot shot down. His carrier-based
A-4 Skyhawk was hit during retaliatory airstrikes on
Vietnamese patrol boats and oil storage facilities
Aug. 5, 1964, not long after the Gulf of Tonkin incident
in which Navy destroyers Maddox and C. Turner Joy reported
coming under North Vietnamese attack.
Alvarez, who ejected not far from shore, was captured
by armed Vietnamese in a fishing vessel. By Aug. 11,
he had been taken to Hanoi's notorious Hoa Lo Prison,
a turn-of-the-century French-built facility with thick
two-story concrete walls known in Vietnamese as the "fiery
furnace." Rats infested his cell. Food, consisting
of animal hooves, chicken heads, rotten fish, and meat
covered with hair, was sickening.
North and South
Prisoners in the North suffered far more extensive
and systematic torture than comrades held captive in
the South. "With the expanding American war effort,
prison authorities were under increasing pressure to
obtain information and statements that could be used
for propaganda purposes," the historians said. "To
produce these they had to break down the PWs' resistance."
The Air Force lost its first pilot in early 1965.
Air Force Lt. Hayden J. Lockhart, flying an F-100,
was seized by the communist forces March 2, 1965, after
evading capture for a week. He was locked in the dreaded
central prison in Hanoi soon thereafter.
The complex, ringed with guard towers, soon became
known as the "Hanoi Hilton," with sections
known as "Heartbreak Hotel," "New Guy
Village," "Little Vegas," and "Camp
Unity." The complex was so formidable that not
a single US serviceman managed to make an escape during
the entire war.
The most systematic torture of American POWs during
the conflict began in fall 1965 and didn't end until
fall 1969, when the Nixon Administration finally went
public with evidence of the mistreatment. An estimated
95 percent of the prisoners in the North experienced
some form of torture.
Navy Lt. j.g. Rodney A. Knutson, a radar intercept
officer captured with pilot Lt. j.g. Ralph E. Gaither
when their F-4 was shot down on Oct. 17, 1965, got
an early taste of what lay ahead. His captors bound
his arms so tightly that they lost circulation. He
was denied food and water. He was beaten. When he still
refused to cooperate, his torturers moved on to a new,
more sinister method-the "rope torture." Knutson
was subjected to this technique on Oct. 25, 1965. The
prisoner was forced face down onto a bunk with his
ankles in stocks and a rope tied at his elbows, with
the rope then pulled up to run through a hook in the
ceiling. The guard hoisted the prisoner off the bunk
so he could not ease any of his weight-producing extreme
pain and constricting breathing.
USAF Capt. Konrad W. Trautman suffered the rope torture
on a dozen occasions. "The pain is literally beyond
description," said Trautman, who was shot down
and captured Oct. 5, 1967. "After about 10 or
15 minutes in this position, tied up so tightly, your
nerves in your arms are pinched off, and then your
whole upper torso becomes numb. It's a relief. You
feel no more pain. ... However when they release the
ropes, the procedure works completely in reverse. It's
almost like double jeopardy-you go through the same
pain coming out of the ropes as you did going in."
|

In 1967, the propaganda war
continued as USAF Lt. Col. James Hughes was
paraded through Hanoi visibly injured the day
after his capture. Such scenes backfired, resulting
in international revulsion at the prisoners'
mistreatment.
|
Hanoi March
On July 6, 1966, 52 prisoners were assembled, blindfolded,
handcuffed in pairs, and taken by truck to downtown
Hanoi. The plan was to parade the Americans in public
view and then use them as props in a war crimes show-trial
to take place at a nearby stadium. This event came
to be known as the "Hanoi March" and is viewed
as a watershed in the propaganda war. "Oh boy,
I love a parade," quipped USAF Capt. Robert B.
Purcell, captive since July 27, 1965, when his F-105
went down 30 miles west of Hanoi.
The prisoners were prodded through the streets at
the point of bayonets, past the Soviet and Chinese
Embassies and through threatening crowds standing 10
deep. One prisoner estimated the crowd as high as 100,000.
Guards incited the angry mob with loudspeakers. Over
a two-mile route, the POWs were punched and pummeled
by flying bricks and bottles. The march highlighted
the lengths to which Hanoi would go to score propaganda
points against the US.
Air Force Capt. Earl G. Cobeil, captured on Nov. 5,
1967, feigned mental illness, as did some other POWs,
to protect himself from the experimental brainwashing
carried out by a dreaded Cuban interrogator. The Cuban,
known among POWs as "Fidel," convinced that
Cobeil was faking, mercilessly beat him day after day.
One day, Cobeil refused to bow. For the offense, Cobeil
on May 21, 1968, was trussed in ropes overnight and
mauled for 24 hours straight. Fidel, enraged, emerged
from one torture session to shout to prisoners within
earshot: "We've got [a POW] that's faking. Nobody's
gonna fake and get away with it. ... I'm gonna teach
you all a lesson. ... I'm gonna break this guy in a
million pieces." Cobeil was last seen in the fall
of 1970 and did not return with the other POWs in 1973.
The Vietnamese later reported Cobeil had died in November
1970; his remains were returned March 6, 1974.
The prisoners believed that, when captured, "their
mission had changed, from one of active fighting to
one of resistance and survival," the Pentagon
historians said. "They still had a soldierly function
to perform-to disrupt, to stymie, to exhaust the enemy,
finally to defeat him, in this case on the battlefield
of propaganda and psychological warfare."
One prisoner estimated that communist torturers exacted
statements of some sort from 80 percent of the POWs.
As soon as they recovered from the physical trauma,
the prisoners faced the torment of having collaborated
and, theoretically, having violated the Code of Conduct.
However, the Code, updated after the Korean War and
reviewed after the USS Pueblo incident off Korea in
1968, assumed that captors would observe the minimum
provisions of the Geneva Convention governing POWs.
Under relentless torture, "the Code increasingly
seemed to be a noble, but meaningless, abstraction
that paled into irrelevance before the harrowing reality
of the ropes and stocks," the historians found.
|

Navy Lt. Cmdr. Hugh Stafford
broke his arm, collarbone, and ribs when his
A-4 was downed by a SAM over Haiphong in August
1967. After three days without water, he was
then subjected to the rope torture. Despite
his injuries (damage to his left arm is evident
in this photo), he became what the study's
authors call "a spark plug in the resistance."
|
Cherry's Ordeal
Vietnamese communists played the race card. Air Force
Maj. Fred V. Cherry, the highest ranking black POW
in the North, recalled his captors trying to exploit
him by treating him differently. The Vietnamese housed
Cherry with Navy Lt. Porter A. Halyburton in apparent
hopes of sowing dissension between a black aviator
and a white Southerner. The tactic backfired. Cherry
later credited Halyburton with saving his life, when
his injuries from being shot down became so infected
that he had to be fed by hand and assisted with his
bodily needs.
Cherry's resistance won him some of the war's most
severe exactions-including one 93-day stretch of unbroken
torture and 53 straight weeks of solitary confinement.
Prisoners fashioned elaborate means of reaching out
to comrades. Navy Lt. Cmdr. Robert H. Shumaker spied
a fellow prisoner in March 1965 and surreptitiously
left a note in the latrine that was never found. Guards
found a second note, and Shumaker was threatened with
punishment. His persistence paid off in the summer
of 1965 when he left another note in the latrine that
was read by Air Force Capt. Ronald E. Storz, downed
while flying a small observation airplane near the
DMZ. Storz scratched his name in reply on a piece of
toilet paper with the burnt end of a match.
"Thus was accomplished the first exchange of
messages among American PWs in North Vietnam," the
historians said.
The names of captured pilots soon appeared on the
undersides of plates and the handles of food pails
as makeshift communications began. By the summer of
1965, Air Force Capt. Carlyle S. Harris perfected and
spread a tap code that became the gold standard for
communication throughout the prisoner population. Harris
recalled the code from survival training at Stead AFB,
Nev., where an instructor had shown him the code during
a coffee break.
The prisoners used a five-by-five grid for the letters
of the alphabet, with two numbers assigned to each
letter. They dropped the "K." Prisoners quickly
reverted to short cuts--so that "God bless you" became
GBU--the universal sign-off.
By the summer of 1966, Navy Cmdr. James B. Stockdale,
the senior officer and the POW leader, had become so
proficient that he carried on a virtual conversation
with Air Force Maj. Samuel R. Johnson, a prisoner in
an adjoining cell.
In his memoir, Stockdale recounted, "Our tapping
ceased to be just an exchange of letters and words;
it became conversation. Elation, sadness, humor, sarcasm,
excitement, depression-all came through. ... I laughed
to think what our friends back home would think of
us two old fighter pilots standing at a wall, checking
for shadows under the door, pecking out a final message
for the day with our fingernails-'Don't let the bedbugs
bite' [DLTBBB]."
The grueling, day-to-day stresses took a toll. A generational
split developed between prisoners captured between
1965 and the bombing suspension of November 1968 and
the younger generation of pilots shot down after resumption
of bombing in December 1971. Newly seized prisoners
tended to be more cynical about the war, the Pentagon
historians found. They also operated under a more flexible
interpretation of the Code of Conduct.
|

Navy Lt. Cmdr. John McCain (now
a US senator) suffered severe injuries in 1967
from bailing out of his A-4 over Hanoi and
being beaten by a mob. A prize hostage because
of his prominent father, he rejected offers
of quick repatriation.
|
"Peace Committee"
Dissension remained an undercurrent.
"In truth, over the years, there would be breakdowns
of authority, lapses in the chain of command, intramural
squabbling, even instances of resentment and outright
disobedience of the leadership," the historians
found. For example, by the fall of 1971, a group of
at least eight enlisted prisoners became known as the "Peace
Committee," its members receptive to the communists'
propaganda. "Whether they were turncoats who willfully
disobeyed orders, ratted on comrades, and bartered
anti-war messages for special privileges, or were simply
confused youngsters who sincerely opposed the war and
saw no downside to expressing their feelings, depends
on the perspective of participants," the historians
said.
In January 1973, after the signing of the Paris peace
accords, freedom drew near. Resentful American prisoners
weighed the idea of executing members of the Peace
Committee. USAF Lt. Col. Theodore W. Guy, the senior
officer in charge at the POW camp called "Plantation," spent
two weeks persuading the angry conspirators to drop
that plan. He also talked them out of a subsequent
plan to shave the Peace Committee members' heads. He
planned to file court-martial charges after their release.
The most prominent turncoat of the war was Marine
Pfc. Robert R. Garwood, 19, a motor pool driver who
disappeared on Sept. 28, 1965, near Da Nang, South
Vietnam. He cooperated with the enemy and remained
in Vietnam long after the other Americans had been
repatriated. Garwood himself voluntarily returned to
the US on March 22, 1979, and was immediately taken
into custody. The historians found that Garwood "did
cross over [to collaboration with the communists] but
that his 'defection' stemmed more from opportunism
than any genuine political or ideological conversion."
Throughout the war, barriers to escape were indeed
formidable, so much so that not a single GI made it
to freedom from North Vietnam, according to the historians.
While the Code of Conduct called for prisoners to "make
every effort to escape," senior commanders realized
that escape attempts triggered such Draconian retaliation
that attempts could jeopardize the lives of other prisoners.
Air Force Capt. John A. Dramesi, who was captured
April 2, 1967, was determined to escape despite the
odds. The pugnacious former star high school wrestler
and son of a boxer had already tried to escape en route
to Hanoi. For months, he and fellow conspirators squirreled
away string, wire, and bamboo that could be used for
tools or weapons. Donated scraps of food were hidden
in a cache. They gathered straw, thread, and cloth
to weave civilian attire. Conical peasant hats were
fabricated from rice straw taken from sleeping mats.
Dramesi acquired brown iodine pills for water purification
and to help darken the skin color of those attempting
to escape. On May 10, 1969, Dramesi and Air Force Capt.
Edwin L. Atterberry advised the leadership, "We're
going tonight."
Horror Chamber
They did. Dramesi calculated that, by dawn, they had
traveled four or five miles from the compound. But
that was it. A North Vietnamese patrol found the pair
hiding in a bramble thicket near an abandoned churchyard.
The two were captured, blindfolded and handcuffed,
and returned to prison. Dramesi was tortured for 38
days, flogged with a fan belt, punched, strapped into
excruciating positions by ropes, and kept awake. He
was strung in the ropes 15 times. Eventually he broke.
In a horror chamber close to Dramesi, the communists
tortured Atterberry so gruesomely that his shrieks
of pain could be heard two blocks away. Atterberry
died on May 18, 1969, just eight days after the breakout.
The communists didn't stop with punishing Dramesi
and Atterberry. They tortured other prisoners-some
for weeks-who had not participated in the escape attempt
and even extended the torture to other prisons.
"So traumatic had been the overall experience
that even when escape became a more feasible option
late in the captivity, the prisoners were still haunted
by the catastrophic consequences of the DramesiAtterberry
attempt," the historians wrote.
To the South, the historians found that about two
dozen Americans-about 10 percent-managed to escape
from their captors and make it to freedom.
Perhaps the most stunning getaway was the one that
was staged by Army Lt. James N. Rowe, a Special Forces
advisor seized Oct. 29, 1963, in the Mekong Delta,
along with Army Capt. Humbert R. Versace and Army Sgt.
Daniel L. Pitzer. Versace later was executed by his
captors. Pitzer was released in 1967.
On Dec. 31, 1968, after more than five years of jungle
captivity, forced marches, starvation, and disease,
Rowe and his Viet Cong guards cowered in the underbrush
to elude US gunships and advancing South Vietnamese
troops seeking battle. Suddenly, Rowe found himself
alone with a single guard. He clubbed the man unconscious,
rushed to a clearing, and waved frantically toward
a descending US helicopter gunship.
Luckily, the commander of the air cavalry group, Army
Maj. David Thompson, spied what he thought was a Viet
Cong guerrilla vulnerable to capture and, rather than
opening fire, swooped in to pick him up. "Only
when the command ship swept in and lifted the black-clad
figure out of the jungle amid a hail of fire from VC
in the woods did the helicopter crew realize that it
had bagged an American," the historians wrote.
Rowe left the Army in 1974, returned to duty in 1980,
and died in April 1989, victim of an ambush by left-wing
Marxist terrorists in the Philippines.
Dreams of escape similarly inspired two GIs who received
the Medal of Honor posthumously for valor during captivity.
Marine Capt. Donald G. Cook remained endlessly defiant
after being captured east of Saigon in late December
1964, when Viet Cong overran the South Vietnamese force
he was advising. Cook nursed civilian Douglas Ramsey,
a US foreign service officer captured in January 1966,
back from a sinking malaria-induced coma and saved
his life, despite the ravages of his own illnesses.
On Dec. 8, 1967, as the POWs were moved to another
camp, Cook died on a jungle trail, probably from a
malaria seizure, stated the historians. Ramsey's account
of Cook's heroism, provided upon his release in 1973,
led the US on May 16, 1980, to bestow on Cook the nation's
highest decoration for valor.
|

As a 19-year-old Air Force Academy
cadet, Lance Sijan learned survival skills
that he later used to elude the North Vietnamese
for 46 days. He received a Medal of Honor posthumously
for his heroic fight for freedom and determined
resistance.
|
Tale of Lance Sijan
Air Force 1st Lt. Lance P. Sijan also received the
Medal of Honor. The backseater on a disabled F-4 that
crashed in Laos on Nov. 9, 1967, Sijan bailed out at
low altitude and evaded capture for 46 days, despite
a compound leg fracture, mangled hand, and head concussion.
North Vietnamese soldiers found him by the side of
the road on Christmas morning 1967. He was taken in
early 1968 to North Vietnam, where he was held with
Air Force Lt. Col. Robert R. Craner and Capt. Guy D.
Gruters. His Air Force Academy buddy Gruters did not
recognize him. The strapping 220-pound former football
player had lost a great amount of weight. His leg was
badly infected, yet he asked his comrades to help him
exercise so he could escape. Sijan died of pneumonia
on Jan. 22, 1968. In March 1976, Sijan was awarded
the Medal of Honor-the first graduate of the Air Force
Academy to receive the award.
Some prisoners were lucky enough to win early release.
Prisoner leaders, including Navy Lt. Cmdr. Richard
A. Stratton and Navy Lt. Cmdr. John S. McCain III (now
a US senator and Presidential candidate) rejected Vietnamese
offers of immediate repatriation, fearing that such
a release would yield a propaganda bonanza for Hanoi
and have a disastrous impact on POW morale and cohesion.
They also thought that such an act would run contrary
to their duty to stay with their men until all were
safe.
On Feb. 16, 1968, in the midst of the Tet Offensive,
North Vietnam released three prisoners from Plantation,
turning them over to peace activists Daniel Berrigan,
a Jesuit priest, and Howard Zinn, a professor of history
and government at Boston University. Navy Ensign David
P. Matheny, a 24-year-old pilot, Air Force Maj. Norris
M. Overly, and Air Force Capt. Jon D. Black were turned
over. The freed officers became known at Plantation
as the "MOB," an acronym for their last names.
The stay-behinds debated whether the freed prisoners
had broken faith. Many saw the value in having Matheny
carry out the memorized names of at least 70 POWs,
helping the Pentagon update the list of captured pilots.
Senior officers became deeply concerned over the possibility
that early release offers could decimate unity. USAF
Lt. Col. Hervey S. Stockman, senior officer at Plantation,
was fearful that his men now knew that Hanoi's "promises
of amnesty were not completely empty." He quickly
issued orders that future releases under the early
release program would be accepted "only in order
of shootdown with sick and wounded first."
Additional releases followed. Navy Seaman Douglas
B. Hegdahl, freed by North Vietnam in 1969, came out
with the first word actually confirming that American
servicemen had been captured by the communists in Laos
and were being held prisoner. Hegdahl, 19, the youngest
POW seized in the North, had been serving as an ammunition
handler aboard the guided-missile cruiser USS Canberra
in the Gulf of Tonkin. During a night bombardment,
he went topside where he was knocked overboard by the
concussion of the ship's guns. He was picked up by
North Vietnamese fishermen and turned over to the militia.
Turning Point
The release of Hegdahl and two others on Aug. 4, 1969,
marked a turning point in the Nixon Administration's
public relations policy, with an end to the low-key
approach to allegations of mistreatment and torture.
The plight of American prisoners was brought to the
attention of the world, and, about that same time,
a new regime took over in North Vietnam upon the death
of Ho Chi Minh. Conditions began to improve in the
prisons of North Vietnam.
By the time of the peace accords, a total of 113 American
POWs had died in captivity. Operation Homecoming saw
the return of 600 prisoners-591 Americans and nine
foreign nationals. The Americans included:
- USAF, 325
- Navy, 138
- Army, 77
- Marines, 26
- Civilians, 25
Air Force Lt. Col. Robinson Risner, a Korean War ace
and test pilot, scored a symbolic victory for the prisoners
at Unity who had just been notified of their impending
release. Risner had been held captive since Sept. 16,
1965. He had commanded the Hanoi Hilton as the senior
officer in charge since Sept. 20, 1965. An interpreter
for the presiding North Vietnamese officer known as
Dog read from a prepared text, telling the prisoners
that they would be released 120 at a time in two week
increments. Dog demanded that the prisoners "show
good attitudes" until release. He then dismissed
the prisoners.
For all of Dog's officiousness, it was not until Risner
did a smart about-face, looked at his men, and issued
the order that the prisoners moved. Risner called the
men to attention. Some 400 men snapped to attention,
and, as one POW remembered it, "the thud of 800
rubber tire sandals coming together smartly was awesome." Squadron
commanders returned Risner's salute and dismissed their
squadrons in unison.
Some prisoners ran into each others arms, hugged,
and whooped with joy. Others felt the weight of their
suffering drain from their bodies, what Navy Lt. Cmdr.
Hugh A. "Al" Stafford called a "profound,
bottomless fatigue."
"What the hell had I done the last seven [years]," wondered
Navy Lt. Gerald L. Coffee, downed while on a photoreconnaissance
mission near Vinh on Feb. 3, 1966. "During the
prime years of my life, I'd sat on my ass in some medieval
dungeons, broken my teeth, screwed up my arm, contracted
worms and God knows what else, and had gotten old."
The vanguard of the prisoners arrived at Clark on
Feb. 12, 1973. It was there that many of the ex-prisoners
finally relinquished the self-control that had enabled
them to survive.
|

USAF Maj. Roger Ingvalson, an
F-105 pilot captured in May 1968, reads what
was called Christmas mail in a propaganda photo,
at top. Navy officers (l-r) Lt. j.g. David
Everett, Lt. Carroll Beeler, and Lt. Cmdr.
Theodore Triebel and USAF Maj. James Padgett
were among the POWs brought forward to meet
an American who traveled to North Vietnam in
fall 1972.
|
One of the Best
Ernest C. Brace, a pilot for a private airline flying
supply missions in Laos and Thailand under contract
to the US Agency for International Development, had
been held since May 21, 1965, the day his small airplane
was ambushed on a runway in Laos.
He "survived barbarous mistreatment and decimating
illness over an eight-year period ... to become one
of the most seasoned and respected PWs among all the
Americans captured in Southeast Asia," the historians
wrote.
But upon hearing that his wife had left him, Brace
broke down and cried at the processing center in an
emotional outpouring that he could not remember yielding
to through all the years of beatings and persecution.
Over three to five days, prisoners called families,
went through debriefings and medical evaluations, and,
in general, decompressed before the trip home.
Air Force Maj. George E. "Bud" Day, captured
Aug. 26, 1967, after being shot down near the DMZ and
later awarded the Medal of Honor for heroism, learned
that some family members had died during his captivity.
Day had managed to escape his initial capture and evade
the enemy for two weeks and was within two miles of
a US Marine outpost when he was shot and recaptured.
His legendary resistance to communist torturers won
him the everlasting respect of his colleagues.
Day recalled feeling "as if I might melt into
the phone" as he spoke to his wife for the first
time in more than five years. "She came through
strong and clear. She was well. The children were well.
They were as anxious to see me as I was to see them.
All of the important things in my existence were in
order."
Lt. John H. Nasmyth, taken captive Sept. 4, 1966,
recalled locating a bathtub in a staff room, locking
the door, and "wallowing" in the hot water
until it spilled over the tub. His first bath lasted
an hour-the first of half a dozen he took the first
night of freedom.
As they prepared to fly home, some ex-prisoners found
it hard to leave fellow POWs who had shared the same
horrific experiences.
"Of course, getting out was what we had all anticipated
and dreamed of," recalled Craner, captured Dec.
20, 1967. "But I and everyone did establish friendships
and very intimate personal relationships up there,
which I don't believe any other set of circumstances
would have allowed. And it was with just a little bit
of melancholia that I finally said goodbye."
At Travis AFB, Calif., Air Force Capt. Peter P. Camerota
got a quick lesson that little had changed. A crew
member on a B-52 that had been shot down in the December
1972 raids, he had eluded capture for 10 days by hiding
in a cave. He knew he was home when he went through
processing and he was told that he would be paid $5
for each of his 88 days in captivity. But, Camerota
explained, he had been in North Vietnamese territory
for 98 days, including the 10 days of evasion.
The official explained that the money was expressly
for "substandard quarters and subsistence" and
that during his 10 days evading capture he had no quarters
and subsistence and therefore did not have substandard
quarters and subsistence.
Coming face to face with that bureaucratic explanation,
said Camerota, "I knew I was home."
|

Operation Homecoming brought
back 600 POWs, including then Maj. R.E. "Gene" Smith,
who was among the jubilant group repatriated
in March 1973 and who went on to become an
AFA president and board chairman. He had been
a POW since 1967.
|
Coming Home
The historians found that some prisoners made the
transition to life back home more easily than others.
"Some picked up their lives as normally as if
they had merely served overseas for the better part
of a decade, and some never recovered from dissolved
marriages, missed career opportunities, or the awful
memories," the study found.
Two returned POWs committed suicide soon after release.
One, Marine Sgt. Abel L. Kavanaugh, was a young man
captured on April 24, 1968, after being inadvertently
left behind by Marine helicopters lifting his unit
back to base camp. Kavanaugh had been a member of the
so-called Peace Committee. He killed himself June 27,
1973.
Ex-prisoners ran for public office, including four
elected to Congress--Denton, McCain, Johnson, and Douglas
B. "Pete" Peterson. Peterson, an Air Force
captain who later represented a Florida Congressional
district, became the first postwar US ambassador to
Vietnam, taking up his post on May 9, 1997.
"Those who made it back gave their countrymen
an occasion to celebrate patriotism and heroism unencumbered
by the vexing moral and political issues that beclouded
so much of the war effort," the Pentagon historians
concluded. "The PWs, even when they were no longer
incarcerated, continued to wield a symbolic power out
of proportion to their small numbers. Their proud return
to a grateful nation remains one of the few truly shining
moments of that troubled era."
Stewart M. Powell, White House correspondent for Hearst
Newspapers, has covered national and international affairs
since 1970 while based in the United States and Britain.
His last article for Air Force Magazine was "
A
Half Century of NATO," which appeared in the
April 1999 issue.
Copyright Air Force Association. All rightsreserved.
|
|
 |