Current Issue
 
 Archives
 Back Issues
 Editorials
 The Chart Page
 Verbatim
 Airpower Classics
 The Keeper File
 Valor
 Enola Gay Controversy
   Chronology
   Reports & Analysis
   Articles & Editorials
 Covers

 Almanacs
 
 Special Topics
 
 Special Reports
 
 Search
 
 Advertising
 
 About the Magazine

Perspectives on the The Big Defense Reviews: From Bottom-Up to QDR

The Destruction of National Defense (Editorial)
May 1993

The Bottom-Down Review (Editorial)
December 1993
The Problem With the Strategy (Editorial)
July 1994
Revelations and Moonshine (Editorial)
September 1994
Backing Up on Strategy (Editorial)
June 1996
Mixed Signals From the Quadrennial Review (Editorial)
July 1997
Projections From the QDR
August 1997
The Headwinds of Tradition (Editorial)
October 1997
NDP and the Transformation Strategy  
March 1998
They Call It Transformation (Editorial)
February 1998
Boren-Rudman Takes Its Turn (Editorial)
December 1998
Duel of Doctrines
December 1998
Aerospace Power Meets the QDR (Editorial)
July 2000
In Pursuit of a Strategy
August 2001
The QDR Goes to War
December 2001
The Legacy of the Bottom-Up Review
October 2003
Weathering the QDR (Editorial)
December 2004
On Rumsfeld's "Terms"
June 2005
The Two-War Strategy Begins to Fade Away
September 2005
Question's for Rumsfeld's Pentagon (Editorial)
October 2005
Four in a Row (Editorial)
December 2005
Battle Damage From the QDR (Editorial)
January 2006
The QDR Has Landed, Sort Of (Editorial)
March 2006
A Force For the Long Run (Editorial)
December 2006



The Destruction of National Defense (Editorial) May 1993
By John T. Correll

At some point--which we may not discern at the time--we will put ourselves on course for the failure of American arms in a future conflict.


The Bottom-Down Review (Editorial) December 1993
By John T. Correll

Mr. Aspin should take his own advice and let requirements determine the defense program.


The Problem With the Strategy (Editorial) July 1994
By John T. Correll

The concept is sound, but the force structure lacks depth. Its capability to fight two regional conflicts is not convincing.


Revelations and Moonshine (Editorial) September 1994
By John T. Correll

The Pentagon admits the forces can't cover the strategy--and GAO says the budget is $150 billion short of covering the forces.


Backing Up on Strategy (Editorial) June 1996
By John T. Correll

There's a movement to drop the two-conflict strategy in favor of a standard similar to Win-Hold-Win.

Mixed Signals From the Quadrennial Review (Editorial) July 1997
By John T. Correll

There is a mismatch between the strategy and the implementing actions of the QDR.


Projections From the QDR August 1997
By John A. Tirpak, Senior Editor  

The Pentagon's latest strategy and forces review will guide the next six years of programming, budgeting, and operations.


The Headwinds of Tradition (Editorial) Ocober 1997
By John T. Correll

Air Force operations not in support of land forces are considered "unjoint." The Pentagon's latest strategy and forces review will guide the next six years of programming, budgeting, and operations.


NDP and the Transformation Strategy March 1998
By John A. Tirpak, Senior Editor

The National Defense Panel would dump the two-conflict strategy and move ahead from there.


They Call It Transformation (Editorial) February 1998
By John T. Correll

The National Defense Panel says that air and space capabilities are critical to the future, but budget and program proposals do not follow suit.


Boren-Rudman Takes Its Turn (Editorial) December 1998
By John T. Correll

This commission could lead to major change for the armed forces. Whether that's good or bad remains to be seen.



Duel of Doctrines December 1998
By Elaine M. Grossman

The land forces believe the decisive defeat of the enemy must occur on the ground. The Air Force believes otherwise.



Aerospace Power Meets the QDR (Editorial) July 2000
By John T. Correll

There is less enthusiasm in the Pentagon than you might think for "transformation."



In Pursuit of a Strategy August 2001
By John T. Correll

The QDR is on a "forced march" with Rumsfeld and top Pentagon leaders calling the cadence.


The QDR Goes to War December 2001
By John A. Tirpak

The Quadrennial Defense Review says homeland defense is the top mission for the armed forces.


The Legacy of the Bottom-Up Review October 2003
By John T. Correll

It was an exercise to justify a blind budget cut, but it shaped the force for a decade.


Weathering the QDR (Editorial) December 2004
By Robert S. Dudney, Editor in Chief

In the upcoming defense review, the Air Force could face a “perfect storm” of pressures.


On Rumsfeld's "Terms" June 2005
By Jason Sherman

The Pentagon chief didn’t ask the services for advice; he set his own agenda for the big defense review.


The Two-War Strategy Begins to Fade Away September 2005
By Jason Sherman

The Rumsfeld Pentagon wants to overhaul the concept and use a very different yardstick for sizing the armed forces.


Question's for Rumsfeld's Pentagon (Editorial) October 2005
By Robert S. Dudney, Editor in Chief

What we will need to know about the big upcoming defense decisions.


Four in a Row (Editorial) December 2005
By Robert S. Dudney, Editor in Chief

Will this QDR wind up stating what the services think they will be permitted to spend, not what they need to spend?


Battle Damage From the QDR (Editorial) January 2006
By Robert S. Dudney, Editor in Chief

The upshot is that the Air Force of future years will be smaller and less capable than it otherwise would be.


The QDR Has Landed, Sort Of March 2006
By Robert S. Dudney, Editor in Chief

The question is: What forces will be available to support this broad national defense strategy?


A Force For the Long Run (Editorial) December 2006
By Robert S. Dudney, Editor in Chief

Some new emphasis on irregular threats was warranted, but overcorrection can be dangerous.


   

Copyright Air Force Association. All rights reserved

 

   
 
 



AFA is a 501c(3) nonprofit educational foundation. Your contributions help support AFA initiatives to educate the public about the need for a strong national defense, advocate aerospace power and directly support our Air Force family are tax deductible.

SEARCH  |  CONTACT US  |  MEMBERS  |  EVENTS  |  JOIN AFA  |  HOME

The Air Force Association, 1501 Lee Highway, Arlington, VA 22209-1198
Contact Webmaster | Design by Steven Levins | Some photos courtesy of USAF